After speaking to each, return to David Torchsong, who will then ask you how to match them all. Be careful what you click- if you make an incorrect match, you will need to start over! The correct pairs are:
Zak and Lysndra both appreciate industry and hard work.
Tyluna and Colt share a love for animals.
Amund and Vixxi each admire fine physical specimens.
Marjorie will please Beldrin with her cooking.
(Alternate pairings are Zak and Colt, Tyluna and Lysndra.)
After giving the matches, David Torchsong will tell you he needs to meditate on your choices. Hail him again to complete the quest and receive your reward.
If you already received an Erollisi Day Cloak from previous years it will NOT be offered as reward again since it is a Lore item.
This article refers to events, personae, items and activities only present in-game during the annual Erollisi Day festivities, which come to Norrath each year for a short time roughly around February 14th.